View Single Post
Old 09-04-2016, 07:25 PM   #43
bigal
Privileged Member
 
bigal's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 835
Reputation: 22595
bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)bigal has a maximum reputation! (1000+)
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by tom8517 View Post
I'm not at all sure it's a German slam dunk with out the Americans. In December '41 the western desert and the battle of the Atlantic were at a stalemate, the Germans were stalled in front of Moscow, all with out American involvement, aside from the material aid..
I agree. Attacking Russia while Britain was still undefeated was a mistake. With American material aid but no military involvement, I think Germany could have been beaten by Russia and Britain. Or at least fought to a standstill and peace terms agreed that would have seen compromises from both sides.
bigal is offline   Reply With Quote